With pricey third-party delivery fees in mind, restaurateurs are looking to first-party ordering channels to save themselves—and their customers—a few bucks.

But while 3PD certainly has its downsides, brands still see benefits in using the platforms, said Wade Allen, president of Win Brands, which owns Costa Vida Fresh Mexican Grill.

“If a family of six wants to go eat somewhere and three of them want to go to different places, 3PD works great,” said Allen, alongside Devon Rosco of Olo and Art Kilmer of Black Bear Diner. The trio sat on a panel about redirecting online orders to first-party channels at the Restaurant Finance & Development Conference last week. “They open up the app, and they [may] order from three different restaurants. Hopefully we’re one of those, and that brings customers in.”

3PD accounts for about a third of Costa Vida’s off-premises sales. Catering and first-party sales make up the other two-thirds.

“It’s something we can’t turn off. We can’t just ignore it,” Allen said. “If [3PD] went away tomorrow … it would be a tough sales loss. So there’s a relationship that we have to have.”

Still, first-party channels remain supreme, he said. And restaurants need systems in place to entice customers to order directly, rather than scrolling through the Uber Eats or DoorDash apps. 

Loyalty points and tailored discounts might sway customers to order directly from the restaurant, as long as ordering is convenient like it is through the apps.

“If you’re going to compete with third-party, you have to level the playing field,” Allen said. “The focus for us at Costa Vida is about making sure that we have parity in those applications with 3PD, so that we can compete head to head and convince our customers: ‘Hey, if I’m going to order Costa, I’m not going to be lazy and go to 3PD. I’m actually going to have the brand in hand on the phone, and I’m going to go order from Costa, and I’ll get incentives, and I’ll get delivery, and I’ll get ease of payment, and I’ll get order history.”

The consumer data that comes along with direct orders is another bonus of first-party channels. If a guest orders through a restaurant’s website or app, the brand can see how often that customer visits, what they order and other key metrics, Allen said.

Roscoe, the director of growth at Olo, said brands drive customer loyalty with good food and convenience, as well as speed and quality of service. Restaurants also need to measure up to a 3PD app’s order-correction process.

“I would say one in four orders that I get delivered to my front door either have a missing item, a bad modification [or] were an hour and a half late, and it’s [the restaurants] that are the face of that,” Roscoe said. “I think resolution around how a guest interacts with you or how you make it right … is a really important piece of that puzzle.”

Through first-party channels, restaurants have a better opportunity to provide the service they want to be known for, Kilmer, the chief operating officer of Black Bear, said. This way, employees can deliver that “surprise and delight” mentality to guests, even if they’re not eating inside.

“Loyalty comes from trust,” he said. “[Through first-party channels] I have a better capability to deliver a closer hospitality experience that I want to reflect what would happen inside our diner if you sat down in our dining room.”